top of page

Low GI vs High GI Foods: Does Glycaemic Load Matter More?

Writer: Morgan Gillham
Morgan Gillham
Oct 30
4 min read

Updated: 21 hours ago



You've probably heard that low GI foods are better for managing blood sugar. But what exactly makes a food low GI, and does that automatically make it a healthier choice?


The answer is a little more complicated than you might expect.


Understanding the difference between glycaemic index (GI) and glycaemic load (GL) can help you make more informed carbohydrate choices, particularly if you're managing prediabetes, insulin resistance or type 2 diabetes.

prediabetes nutritionist checking blood glucose

What is the glycaemic index (GI)?


The glycaemic index is a ranking system that measures how carbohydrate-containing foods affect blood glucose levels.


Foods are classified as:


- Low GI: 55 or less

- Medium GI: 56–69

- High GI: 70 or above


Generally, lower-GI foods produce a slower, more gradual blood glucose response, while higher-GI foods tend to produce a faster and larger response when equal amounts of available carbohydrate are compared.


For example, lentils, traditional rolled oats and many wholegrain breads have a lower GI than foods such as cornflakes or jasmine rice.


However, GI doesn't tell us everything about how a food will affect your blood glucose.


What is glycaemic load (GL)?


Glycaemic load takes GI one step further.


While GI measures how a food's carbohydrates affect blood glucose under standardised testing conditions, glycaemic load also considers how much carbohydrate is actually present in the portion you're eating.


This matters because we don't always eat equal amounts of carbohydrate from different foods.


Take watermelon, for example.


Watermelon can have a relatively high GI, but because it contains a lot of water and relatively little carbohydrate per serving, its glycaemic load is low.


In other words, a high-GI food doesn't necessarily have a large effect on blood glucose when eaten in a typical portion.


On the other hand, eating a large serving of a low-GI carbohydrate food can still provide a substantial amount of carbohydrate.


Both the type and quantity of carbohydrate matter.


Does low GI automatically mean healthier?


Not necessarily.


GI tells us about the blood glucose response to a food's carbohydrates, but it doesn't tell us about its overall nutritional value.


For example, some foods containing substantial amounts of fat may have a lower GI because fat slows digestion, even if they're high in saturated fat or relatively low in other nutrients.


Meanwhile, foods such as watermelon can have a higher GI but still provide vitamins, fluid and other beneficial nutrients.


That's why it's important to consider the bigger picture, including fibre, protein, fats, vitamins, minerals and overall dietary quality.


What about eating different foods together?


GI values are measured under controlled conditions, but most of us eat mixed meals rather than individual carbohydrate foods.


Adding protein, fibre or fat to a meal can influence digestion and the blood glucose response.


For example, a bowl of rice eaten on its own may produce a different response from rice served with chicken, vegetables and olive oil.


Other factors, including cooking methods, food processing and ripeness, can also affect GI.


This means the way you prepare and combine foods can be just as relevant as the GI number on a food list.


Are low GI diets better for prediabetes?


Research suggests that lower-GI and lower-GL dietary patterns can support blood glucose management.


A systematic review and meta-analysis published in The BMJ found that lower-GI/GL diets produced modest improvements in HbA1c and several other cardiometabolic risk factors among people with diabetes.


Research involving people with prediabetes is also promising, although more long-term studies are needed.


Importantly, these findings don't mean everyone needs to follow a strict low-GI diet.


The overall quality of your diet, the amount of carbohydrate you consume, physical activity and individual health circumstances all influence blood glucose management.


How can you use GI and GL in everyday eating?


You don't need to calculate the glycaemic load of every meal to benefit from understanding these concepts.


Instead, consider a few practical changes:


Choose higher-fibre carbohydrates more often. Try traditional oats instead of highly refined breakfast cereals, or include lentils and beans in your meals.


Consider portions. Even low-GI foods contribute carbohydrate, so the amount you eat still matters.


Build balanced meals. Include vegetables, protein and healthy fats alongside carbohydrate-rich foods.


Don't judge foods by GI alone. Fruit, vegetables and other nutritious foods don't need to be avoided simply because they have a higher GI.


Think about your overall eating pattern. Consistent, sustainable improvements are generally more useful than trying to achieve a perfect GI score.


The bottom line


Glycaemic index helps us understand how different carbohydrate foods affect blood glucose, while glycaemic load adds important information about the amount of carbohydrate in a serving.


Neither measure tells the whole story.


For most people, focusing on carbohydrate quality, appropriate portions, balanced meals and overall dietary habits is a more practical approach than memorising GI numbers.


At Crave Wellness Co, we help people understand the science behind nutrition and apply it to everyday eating, without unnecessary restrictions or complicated food rules.


Want practical, personalised nutrition support with prediabetes, insulin resistance or blood glucose management? Explore our nutrition services, online nutrition consultations or book a free 15-minute discovery call.



References


1. Diabetes Australia. Carbohydrates, protein and fats. https://www.diabetesaustralia.com.au/living-with-diabetes/carbs-protein-fats/

3. Chiavaroli, L., et al. (2021). Effect of low glycaemic index or load dietary patterns on glycaemic control and cardiometabolic risk factors in diabetes: Systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. BMJ, 374, n1651. ²

4. Peres, M et al.The Health Effects of Low Glycemic Index and Low Glycemic Load Interventions on Prediabetes and Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: A Literature Review of RCTs. (2023). Nutrients, 15(24), 5060. https://doi.org/10.3390/nu15245060


 
 
 

Comments


Crave Wellness Co  - Nutritionist Wollongong logo

Here at Crave Wellness Co our Wollongong Nutritionists are here to help you decode nutrition information and support you towards your health and nutrition goals.

Contact Us

​

Phone:

0451 579 442

​

Address:

Woonona, NSW, 2517, Australia

​

Servicing:

Wollongong and the Illawarra, Online Australia-wide

​

Email:

hello@cravewellnessco.com.au

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

© 2026 Crave Wellness Co. ABN 89 533 125 463. All rights reserved.

bottom of page